Miller, John, and bbarry had instant chemistry and continued recording after those first 2 nights, coming together to create music after work, at odd hours, or simply on the fly. Early on, they knew they had something special. Something different. And, they wanted that difference to be the hallmark of their melody-making.
The trio was soon joined by Mike Underwood, John's younger brother, who took up the task of Jewel drummer. Mike became the go-to for what was cool and not cool. bbarry once said, "If Mikey doesn't laugh, it's not good." After a slow start, "Mikey" became a formidable force on the skins (powered not only by his insatiable hunger for BEEF, but by his love of Korn and Metallica). As a quartet, the band grew creatively.
When asked during a Delaware radio interview, bbarry commented, "We have a weird combo of musical tastes/influences. Miller likes the Cure and old school rap, John is a Pixies and Church fan, I listen to mostly anything except country, and Mikey likes Korn." With this eclectic pallet of musical interests, the band was geared to make their mark on an industry inundated with grunge rock and punk evolutionists.
By 1994, they had created several basement tapes, played a few live shows, and were thirsty for more. After noticing an hysterical ad in the paper, they made an appointment with the legendary Tim Gilles at Big Blue Meenie (BBM) Studios (then located in Gilles's Hackensack, NJ home).
There, they were beaten by Gilles and nearly drove him to the brink of insanity with their pranks and incessant giggling. Bbarry says, "Creativity needs other outlets besides music. We made Mr. GIlles the man he is today." Of the Jewels, Gilles would say, "Every time they were on the calendar, I would get psychosomatically ill. The first album nearly killed me, but it was one of the best I've ever worked on." Many experts agree he should have known something was up when the band showed up for their first appointment and planted 20 bee-themed wind catchers in his front lawn before ringing the bell.
Upon entering BBM, the band got down to business and recorded songs like, "Blinky," "The Number 9 is Assinine," and "Inflate to 20lbs." Most notably, they completed their first single, "Happy as a Fly," a clear vinyl 7 inch record with a B-side entitled, "Phone Sex Girls (aren't pretty)."
The single became an instant underground hit and, through college airplay, the band was on the local radar. To follow up their hit, they shelved their original recordings and reached deep into their bag of tricks for more. By 1996, they recorded their first album with Gilles and were soon signed to a distribution deal with Black Pumpkin Records, home to punk legends The Fiendz.